Creepypasta is a very good description of it? It felt like it was supposed to be this huge gotcha moment but there was so much set up for such a little thing that it just didn't work for me.

TBH I was also underwhelmed by the dead bird scene - I have dogs that like to pick up dead animals outside so my first thought ws more "Oh, god, cleaning that up would be so exhausting," and then I just couldn't get into it. I was really interested in the wren hunt photos though and a little frustrated by how little we found out about what the villagers knew.